Skip to content
Stronger today.
Brighter tomorrow.Evidence. Options.
A healthier you.

Probiotic Supplements

Compare probiotic supplements by strain, daily CFU, price, testing evidence and label transparency. Understand what the research says about different formulations.

We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Affiliate relationships never determine our scores or rankings.

25products compared
2formulations compared
$0.07 – $1.53per day
2with verified testing evidence

Our Top Picks for Probiotics

View all Probiotics products
Best Overall

Garden of Life Dr. Formulated Once Daily Men’s 50bn CFU – 30 Capsules

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
20/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
21/25
Value
11/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
10/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Recognised certification
Manufacturer statement
Nutrasource registry page for "Dr. Formulated Probiotics Once Daily Men's" states: "IGEN™ Certified" and "This product has PASSED because it does not contain detectable amounts of genetically engineered GMO proteins and genes included in the IGEN™ testing panel."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Nutrasource / IGEN™
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:51:17
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsule15 live strains
Daily dose
50 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
$0.92per day
$27.59per pack
Best Tested

Garden of Life Dr. Formulated Once Daily Men’s 50bn CFU – 30 Capsules

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
20/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
21/25
Value
11/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
10/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Recognised certification
Manufacturer statement
Nutrasource registry page for "Dr. Formulated Probiotics Once Daily Men's" states: "IGEN™ Certified" and "This product has PASSED because it does not contain detectable amounts of genetically engineered GMO proteins and genes included in the IGEN™ testing panel."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Nutrasource / IGEN™
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:51:17
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsule15 live strains
Daily dose
50 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
$0.92per day
$27.59per pack
Cheapest Per Day

Amazon Basics Probiotic 5bn CFU – 60 Capsules

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
4/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
20/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Testing evidence
Evidence status
No public evidence located
Manufacturer statement
Not recorded
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:50:10
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsule8 live strainswith prebiotic
Daily dose
5 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
$0.14per day
$8.69per pack

Compare Probiotics Products

25 products

Daily CFU is the verified live count for the labelled daily serving. Compare the exact strains and whether that count is guaranteed through expiry; do not assume more CFU or more strains is better. Where directions give a range, the range is shown and daily cost uses the low end (no directions: one unit a day). Read the dose guide ↓

Probiotics product comparison
#ProductStrains / formulationDaily dosePrice/dayTestingScore
1Garden of Life Dr. Formulated Once Daily Men’s 50bn CFU – 30 CapsulesGarden of Life30 capsulesMulti-strain blendCapsule15 live strains50 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.92per day$27.59 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Recognised certification
Manufacturer statement
Nutrasource registry page for "Dr. Formulated Probiotics Once Daily Men's" states: "IGEN™ Certified" and "This product has PASSED because it does not contain detectable amounts of genetically engineered GMO proteins and genes included in the IGEN™ testing panel."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Nutrasource / IGEN™
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:51:17
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
20/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
21/25
Value
11/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
10/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
2Garden of Life Dr. Formulated Once Daily Women’s 50bn CFU – 30 CapsulesGarden of Life30 capsulesMulti-strain blendCapsule16 live strains50 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.90per day$26.90 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Recognised certification
Manufacturer statement
NSF Official Listings for Garden of Life, LLC include 'WF Dr Formulated Probiotic Womens pH 40B' under NSF/ANSI Standard 173 Dietary Supplements, confirming a Garden of Life women’s probiotic product is NSF-listed/certified on NSF’s own registry.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
NSF International
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 14:00:18
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
20/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
11/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
3NatureBell Probiotics+ 40 strains with prebiotics and enzymes (Bacillus spores and Saccharomyces included) 200bn CFU – 240 CapsulesNatureBell240 capsulesMulti-strain blendYeastCapsule40 live strainswith prebiotic200 billion CFUAbove typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.22per day$26.99 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer product page says: "Made with non-GMO ingredients and produced in a cGMP-compliant facility. Third-party lab tested and made without gluten, soy & dairy." Amazon image also shows a generic "Certification of Analysis Third-Party Independent Verified Lab Results" panel, but I did not find an independently verifiable lab report or certifying-body registry entry for this specific product.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:44:49
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
19/20
Dose transparency
14/15
Manufacturer transparency
9/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
4TruBiotics 2bn CFU – 60 CapsulesTruBiotics60 capsulesMulti-strain blendExact strainsCapsule2 live strainswith prebiotic2 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.42per day$24.97 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer site says: "Our strains are tested via both in-vitro testing, and, where possible, in-vivo trials." and the product page says it is "developed and proven especially to be taken alongside a course of antibiotics."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:38:42
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
24/25
Value
17/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
5Nutricost Probiotic Complex 50bn CFU – 60 CapsulesNutricost60 capsulesMulti-strain blendCapsule50 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.33per day$19.95 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Nutricost product page states: "Third-Party Tested †" and "Nutricost products are tested by an independent, accredited lab to help verify that what’s on the label is what’s in the bottle."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:46:03
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
18/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
6Align 24/7 Digestive Support 5bn CFU – 56 CapsulesAlign56 capsulesSingle strainExact strainsCapsule1 live strain5 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.76per day$42.42 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer site says: "Each lot is DNA tested to ensure it contains our unique strain, Bifidobacterium 35624TM" and also "guaranteed potency" / "advanced packaging to ensure potency and survivability."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:46:59
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
24/25
Value
13/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
7BioSchwartz Probiotic with organic prebiotics 40bn CFU – 60 CapsulesBioSchwartz60 capsulesMulti-strain blendCapsulewith prebiotic40 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.73per day$21.97 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
BioSchwartz FAQ includes the question “Are your products tested for purity & quality?” but I did not find any independently verifiable lab report, COA, or third-party certification for this specific probiotic product.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:41:04
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
13/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
9/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
8Nature’s Bounty Probiotic 10 20bn CFU – 30 CapsulesNature’s Bounty30 capsulesMulti-strain blendCapsule10 live strains20 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.45per day$13.63 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Nature's Bounty says: "Every Nature’s Bounty® product is subjected to numerous quality tests and assays throughout the manufacturing process to verify purity and full potency. As an added measure of quality assurance, the initial ingredients, as well as the final product are tested in our microbiological laboratory..." and also says its facilities were audited by USP and STR.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:54:56
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
16/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
9Hyperbiotics Vital Nutrients Pro-15 5bn CFU – 60 TabletsHyperbiotics60 tabletsMulti-strain blendTablet15 live strainswith prebiotic5 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.55per day$33.18 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer site says: "Our rigorous quality assurance program includes third-party independent laboratory testing of raw ingredients and finished products for purity and potency to ensure what’s on the label matches what’s in the bottle." It also says the product is "manufactured in a US-based NSF-certified facility."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:43:19
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
20/25
Value
15/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
10Culturelle Pro Strength 12bn CFU – 60 CapsulesCulturelle60 capsulesSingle strainExact strainsCapsule1 live strain12 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.52per day$30.99 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
No public evidence located
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer site says the product is 'clinically studied' and 'clinically proven effective' and that it has 'GUARANTEED POTENCY***' / 'We measure the number of live probiotics at product expiration date, guaranteeing you get the full amount per our label whenever you purchase them.'
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 14:01:59
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
4/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
22/25
Value
15/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
7/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
11Amazon Basics Probiotic 5bn CFU – 60 CapsulesAmazon Basics60 capsulesMulti-strain blendCapsule8 live strainswith prebiotic5 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.14per day$8.69 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
No public evidence located
Manufacturer statement
Not recorded
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:50:10
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
4/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
20/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
12Sports Research Daily Probiotics 60bn CFU – 30 CapsulesSports Research30 capsulesMulti-strain blendCapsule12 live strainswith prebiotic60 billion CFUAbove typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.83per day$24.95 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Sports Research product page states: "Third Party Tested Certified" and "Third Party Tested" for Probiotic 60 Billion (30 veggie capsules).
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:52:22
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
12/20
Dose transparency
14/15
Manufacturer transparency
9/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
13NOW Probiotic-10 25bn CFU – 100 CapsulesNOW100 capsulesMulti-strain blendCapsule10 live strains25–50 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.25per day$25.05 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
No public evidence located
Manufacturer statement
NOW product page says: "The probiotic strains in this product have been identity-verified using DNA-fingerprinting technology." It also says: "This product is formulated to deliver a potency of 25 billion CFU through the Best By date."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:44:00
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
4/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
19/20
Dose transparency
11/15
Manufacturer transparency
9/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
14Garden of Life RAW Probiotics Ultimate Care 100bn CFU – 30 CapsulesGarden of Life30 capsulesMulti-strain blendYeastCapsule34 live strains100 billion CFUAbove typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$1.40per day$41.99 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Garden of Life’s own certifications page says: “When you see these certifications, you can be sure our products undergo a thorough testing process” and specifically describes NSF Certified for Sport as meaning products are free from banned substances; the product image also shows NSF Gluten-Free and Non-GMO Project Verified badges, but I did not find an independent registry page confirming this specific probiotic product is certified.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:48:35
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
21/25
Value
9/20
Dose transparency
14/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
10/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
15NewRhythm Probiotics 50bn CFU – 60 CapsulesNewRhythm60 capsulesMulti-strain blendCapsule20 live strains50 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.57per day$16.99 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer product page states: "Our products are third party tested by independent parties" and links "View Third-Party Lab Results" on the NewRhythm 50 Billion Probiotics Capsules page.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:54:01
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
14/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
16Amazon Basics Solimo Prebiotic & Probiotic Gummies 2bn CFU – 50 GummiesAmazon Basics50 gummiesNot disclosedGummywith prebiotic2 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.34per day$8.53 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
No public evidence located
Manufacturer statement
Not recorded
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 14:05:36
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
4/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
16/25
Value
18/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
9/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
17Balance ONE 15bn CFU – 60 TabletsBalance ONE60 tabletsMulti-strain blendTablet12 live strains15–45 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.53per day$31.97 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Balance ONE’s guarantee page says: “Every formula is crafted with care, third-party tested for purity and quality, and designed to support your wellness.” The product page also says “Vegan • Non-GMO • Gluten & dairy free • Third-party tested” and the homepage says “Blended in the USA and third-party tested” / “Lab-tested for potency & identity.”
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:41:51
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
15/20
Dose transparency
11/15
Manufacturer transparency
7/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
18Physician’s CHOICE Probiotics 60bn CFU – 30 CapsulesPhysician’s Choice30 capsulesMulti-strain blendCapsule10 live strainswith prebiotic60 billion CFUAbove typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.83per day$24.97 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer site states: "We work with independent laboratories, including Eurofins and Light Labs, to test our products for purity, potency, and safety." The product page also says: "Supplement Facts & Certifications ... Non-GMO Project Verified | Third-Party Tested | Manufactured in the USA."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:59:34
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
12/20
Dose transparency
14/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
19Nature’s Bounty Probiotic Acidophilus Tablets – 120 TabletsNature’s Bounty120 tabletsSingle strainTablet1 live strainAmount not stated$0.07per day$8.26 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Nature’s Bounty’s U.S. product page for Acidophilus Probiotic says the supplement contains over 100 million active Lactobacillus Acidophilus cultures. The same page includes a generic review snippet stating: “TESTED TO BE TRUSTED We require that all vitamins & supplements to be third-party tested to help ensure they contain the listed dietary ingredients.” Nature’s Bounty’s FAQ pages also use broad marketing language such as “We offer trusted products, backed by science and made with great ingredients.” I did not find an independently verifiable COA, lab report, or registry entry for this specific product.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:56:55
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
20/20
Dose transparency
7/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
6/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
20Digestive Advantage Daily Probiotic Gummies 1bn CFU – 80 GummiesDigestive Advantage80 gummiesSingle strainExact strainsGummy1 live strain1 billion CFUBelow typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.43per day$17.17 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer site says: "The Advantage? Our clinically tested BC30 probiotic is protected by a natural protein shell which allows it to survive your stomach acid 100x better versus yogurts so more live bacteria can reach your gut." The brand page also says: "All Digestive Advantage probiotic supplements contain our exclusive BC30 Probiotic... studies have shown it can survive 100x better..."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:36:23
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
11/20
Dose transparency
9/15
Manufacturer transparency
7/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
21Align Pro Formula 1bn CFU – 63 CapsulesAlign63 capsulesSingle strainExact strainsCapsule1 live strain1 billion CFUBelow typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.95per day$59.99 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer page says: "DNA testing confirms the identity of Align." It also says the strain is "clinically studied," but that is efficacy research, not independent contents testing.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:57:53
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
7/20
Dose transparency
9/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
22Florastor – 100 CapsulesFlorastor100 capsulesSingle strainYeastExact strainsCapsule1 live strainAmount not stated$1.36per day$67.99 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Florastor’s own product page says “Rigorous quality testing” and “Made in France, every Florastor Dual Action capsule meets the highest quality standards.” The Amazon listing also says “Scientifically-tested bio cultures complex with NCFM®,” but I did not find any independently verifiable third-party COA/certification for this specific product.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 14:03:15
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
10/20
Dose transparency
7/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
6/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
23Thorne Complete Biotic – 30 PowdersThorne30 powdersMulti-strain blendPowderwith prebioticAmount not stated$1.53per day$46.00 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
No public evidence located
Manufacturer statement
NSF Certified for Sport listing for Thorne® Complete Biotic on NSF's own registry shows the product name, brand, product form 'Stick', serving size '1 stick pack (1 g)', and the product is listed under Thorne in the certified products directory.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:39:55
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
4/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
9/20
Dose transparency
7/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
7/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
24OLLY Probiotic + Prebiotic Gummy 0.5bn CFU – 30 GummiesBetterYou Iron 10 mg Oral Spray30 gummiesNot disclosedGummywith prebiotic0.5 billion CFUBelow typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.43per day$12.87 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
OLLY product page states: "NSF Certified" and "NSF certification helps consumers identify products that have been independently tested and certified to meet rigorous standards for quality, safety, and label claims." NSF's own listing page for OLLY confirms the brand's certified products and includes "PROBIOTIC + PREBIOTIC" as a finished product under NSF/ANSI Standard 173.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 14:03:40
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
11/25
Value
9/20
Dose transparency
7/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
25BioGaia Gastrus 0.2bn CFU – 30 TabletsBioGaia30 tabletsMulti-strain blendExact strainsTablet2 live strains0.2 billion CFUBelow typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day$0.58per day$17.50 per packBuy Nowon AmazonTesting evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
FODMAP Friendly product page for BioGaia product: “BioGaia® Gastrus™ PURE ACTION is an extra-strength probiotic... ✓ FODMAP Friendly ...” and “BioGaia® Gastrus® PURE is FODMAP Friendly® certified – it has been independently tested in NATA and ISO-accredited labs...”
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:37:31
Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
15/25
Value
6/20
Dose transparency
0/15
Manufacturer transparency
7/10
Label/ingredient transparency
7/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
#1

Garden of Life Dr. Formulated Once Daily Men’s 50bn CFU – 30 Capsules

Garden of Life

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
20/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
21/25
Value
11/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
10/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsule15 live strains
Daily dose
50 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Recognised certification
Manufacturer statement
Nutrasource registry page for "Dr. Formulated Probiotics Once Daily Men's" states: "IGEN™ Certified" and "This product has PASSED because it does not contain detectable amounts of genetically engineered GMO proteins and genes included in the IGEN™ testing panel."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Nutrasource / IGEN™
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:51:17
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
1
Pack size
30 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.92per day$27.59 per pack
#2

Garden of Life Dr. Formulated Once Daily Women’s 50bn CFU – 30 Capsules

Garden of Life

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
20/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
11/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsule16 live strains
Daily dose
50 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Recognised certification
Manufacturer statement
NSF Official Listings for Garden of Life, LLC include 'WF Dr Formulated Probiotic Womens pH 40B' under NSF/ANSI Standard 173 Dietary Supplements, confirming a Garden of Life women’s probiotic product is NSF-listed/certified on NSF’s own registry.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
NSF International
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 14:00:18
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
1
Pack size
30 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.90per day$26.90 per pack
#3

NatureBell Probiotics+ 40 strains with prebiotics and enzymes (Bacillus spores and Saccharomyces included) 200bn CFU – 240 Capsules

NatureBell

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
19/20
Dose transparency
14/15
Manufacturer transparency
9/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendYeastCapsule40 live strainswith prebiotic
Daily dose
200 billion CFUAbove typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer product page says: "Made with non-GMO ingredients and produced in a cGMP-compliant facility. Third-party lab tested and made without gluten, soy & dairy." Amazon image also shows a generic "Certification of Analysis Third-Party Independent Verified Lab Results" panel, but I did not find an independently verifiable lab report or certifying-body registry entry for this specific product.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:44:49
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
2 capsules
Servings/day
1
Pack size
240 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.22per day$26.99 per pack
#4

TruBiotics 2bn CFU – 60 Capsules

TruBiotics

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
24/25
Value
17/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendExact strainsCapsule2 live strainswith prebiotic
Daily dose
2 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer site says: "Our strains are tested via both in-vitro testing, and, where possible, in-vivo trials." and the product page says it is "developed and proven especially to be taken alongside a course of antibiotics."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:38:42
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
1
Pack size
60 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.42per day$24.97 per pack
#5

Nutricost Probiotic Complex 50bn CFU – 60 Capsules

Nutricost

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
18/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsule
Daily dose
50 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Nutricost product page states: "Third-Party Tested †" and "Nutricost products are tested by an independent, accredited lab to help verify that what’s on the label is what’s in the bottle."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:46:03
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
1
Pack size
60 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.33per day$19.95 per pack
#6

Align 24/7 Digestive Support 5bn CFU – 56 Capsules

Align

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
24/25
Value
13/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Single strainExact strainsCapsule1 live strain
Daily dose
5 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer site says: "Each lot is DNA tested to ensure it contains our unique strain, Bifidobacterium 35624TM" and also "guaranteed potency" / "advanced packaging to ensure potency and survivability."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:46:59
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
1
Pack size
56 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.76per day$42.42 per pack
#7

BioSchwartz Probiotic with organic prebiotics 40bn CFU – 60 Capsules

BioSchwartz

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
13/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
9/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsulewith prebiotic
Daily dose
40 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
BioSchwartz FAQ includes the question “Are your products tested for purity & quality?” but I did not find any independently verifiable lab report, COA, or third-party certification for this specific probiotic product.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:41:04
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
2 capsules
Servings/day
1
Pack size
60 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.73per day$21.97 per pack
#8

Nature’s Bounty Probiotic 10 20bn CFU – 30 Capsules

Nature’s Bounty

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
16/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsule10 live strains
Daily dose
20 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Nature's Bounty says: "Every Nature’s Bounty® product is subjected to numerous quality tests and assays throughout the manufacturing process to verify purity and full potency. As an added measure of quality assurance, the initial ingredients, as well as the final product are tested in our microbiological laboratory..." and also says its facilities were audited by USP and STR.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:54:56
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
1
Pack size
30 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.45per day$13.63 per pack
#9

Hyperbiotics Vital Nutrients Pro-15 5bn CFU – 60 Tablets

Hyperbiotics

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
20/25
Value
15/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendTablet15 live strainswith prebiotic
Daily dose
5 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer site says: "Our rigorous quality assurance program includes third-party independent laboratory testing of raw ingredients and finished products for purity and potency to ensure what’s on the label matches what’s in the bottle." It also says the product is "manufactured in a US-based NSF-certified facility."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:43:19
Formulation & serving details
Format
Tablet
Serving
1 tablet
Servings/day
1
Pack size
60 tablets

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.55per day$33.18 per pack
#10

Culturelle Pro Strength 12bn CFU – 60 Capsules

Culturelle

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
4/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
22/25
Value
15/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
7/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Single strainExact strainsCapsule1 live strain
Daily dose
12 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
No public evidence located
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer site says the product is 'clinically studied' and 'clinically proven effective' and that it has 'GUARANTEED POTENCY***' / 'We measure the number of live probiotics at product expiration date, guaranteeing you get the full amount per our label whenever you purchase them.'
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 14:01:59
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
1
Pack size
60 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.52per day$30.99 per pack
#11

Amazon Basics Probiotic 5bn CFU – 60 Capsules

Amazon Basics

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
4/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
20/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsule8 live strainswith prebiotic
Daily dose
5 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
No public evidence located
Manufacturer statement
Not recorded
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:50:10
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
1
Pack size
60 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.14per day$8.69 per pack
#12

Sports Research Daily Probiotics 60bn CFU – 30 Capsules

Sports Research

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
12/20
Dose transparency
14/15
Manufacturer transparency
9/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsule12 live strainswith prebiotic
Daily dose
60 billion CFUAbove typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Sports Research product page states: "Third Party Tested Certified" and "Third Party Tested" for Probiotic 60 Billion (30 veggie capsules).
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:52:22
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
1
Pack size
30 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.83per day$24.95 per pack
#13

NOW Probiotic-10 25bn CFU – 100 Capsules

NOW

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
4/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
19/20
Dose transparency
11/15
Manufacturer transparency
9/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsule10 live strains
Daily dose
25–50 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
No public evidence located
Manufacturer statement
NOW product page says: "The probiotic strains in this product have been identity-verified using DNA-fingerprinting technology." It also says: "This product is formulated to deliver a potency of 25 billion CFU through the Best By date."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:44:00
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
Not disclosed
Pack size
100 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.25per day$25.05 per pack
#14

Garden of Life RAW Probiotics Ultimate Care 100bn CFU – 30 Capsules

Garden of Life

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
21/25
Value
9/20
Dose transparency
14/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
10/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendYeastCapsule34 live strains
Daily dose
100 billion CFUAbove typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Garden of Life’s own certifications page says: “When you see these certifications, you can be sure our products undergo a thorough testing process” and specifically describes NSF Certified for Sport as meaning products are free from banned substances; the product image also shows NSF Gluten-Free and Non-GMO Project Verified badges, but I did not find an independent registry page confirming this specific probiotic product is certified.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:48:35
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
1
Pack size
30 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$1.40per day$41.99 per pack
#15

NewRhythm Probiotics 50bn CFU – 60 Capsules

NewRhythm

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
14/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsule20 live strains
Daily dose
50 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer product page states: "Our products are third party tested by independent parties" and links "View Third-Party Lab Results" on the NewRhythm 50 Billion Probiotics Capsules page.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:54:01
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
2 capsules
Servings/day
1
Pack size
60 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.57per day$16.99 per pack
#16

Amazon Basics Solimo Prebiotic & Probiotic Gummies 2bn CFU – 50 Gummies

Amazon Basics

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
4/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
16/25
Value
18/20
Dose transparency
15/15
Manufacturer transparency
9/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Not disclosedGummywith prebiotic
Daily dose
2 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
No public evidence located
Manufacturer statement
Not recorded
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 14:05:36
Formulation & serving details
Format
Gummy
Serving
2 gummys
Servings/day
1
Pack size
50 gummies

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.34per day$8.53 per pack
#17

Balance ONE 15bn CFU – 60 Tablets

Balance ONE

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
15/20
Dose transparency
11/15
Manufacturer transparency
7/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendTablet12 live strains
Daily dose
15–45 billion CFUWithin typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Balance ONE’s guarantee page says: “Every formula is crafted with care, third-party tested for purity and quality, and designed to support your wellness.” The product page also says “Vegan • Non-GMO • Gluten & dairy free • Third-party tested” and the homepage says “Blended in the USA and third-party tested” / “Lab-tested for potency & identity.”
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:41:51
Formulation & serving details
Format
Tablet
Serving
1 tablet
Servings/day
Not disclosed
Pack size
60 tablets

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.53per day$31.97 per pack
#18

Physician’s CHOICE Probiotics 60bn CFU – 30 Capsules

Physician’s Choice

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
12/20
Dose transparency
14/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendCapsule10 live strainswith prebiotic
Daily dose
60 billion CFUAbove typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer site states: "We work with independent laboratories, including Eurofins and Light Labs, to test our products for purity, potency, and safety." The product page also says: "Supplement Facts & Certifications ... Non-GMO Project Verified | Third-Party Tested | Manufactured in the USA."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:59:34
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
1
Pack size
30 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.83per day$24.97 per pack
#19

Nature’s Bounty Probiotic Acidophilus Tablets – 120 Tablets

Nature’s Bounty

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
20/20
Dose transparency
7/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
6/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Single strainTablet1 live strain
Daily dose
Amount not stated
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Nature’s Bounty’s U.S. product page for Acidophilus Probiotic says the supplement contains over 100 million active Lactobacillus Acidophilus cultures. The same page includes a generic review snippet stating: “TESTED TO BE TRUSTED We require that all vitamins & supplements to be third-party tested to help ensure they contain the listed dietary ingredients.” Nature’s Bounty’s FAQ pages also use broad marketing language such as “We offer trusted products, backed by science and made with great ingredients.” I did not find an independently verifiable COA, lab report, or registry entry for this specific product.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:56:55
Formulation & serving details
Format
Tablet
Serving
1 tablet
Servings/day
1
Pack size
120 tablets

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.07per day$8.26 per pack
#20

Digestive Advantage Daily Probiotic Gummies 1bn CFU – 80 Gummies

Digestive Advantage

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
11/20
Dose transparency
9/15
Manufacturer transparency
7/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Single strainExact strainsGummy1 live strain
Daily dose
1 billion CFUBelow typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer site says: "The Advantage? Our clinically tested BC30 probiotic is protected by a natural protein shell which allows it to survive your stomach acid 100x better versus yogurts so more live bacteria can reach your gut." The brand page also says: "All Digestive Advantage probiotic supplements contain our exclusive BC30 Probiotic... studies have shown it can survive 100x better..."
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:36:23
Formulation & serving details
Format
Gummy
Serving
2 gummys
Servings/day
1
Pack size
80 gummies

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.43per day$17.17 per pack
#21

Align Pro Formula 1bn CFU – 63 Capsules

Align

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
7/20
Dose transparency
9/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
9/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Single strainExact strainsCapsule1 live strain
Daily dose
1 billion CFUBelow typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Manufacturer page says: "DNA testing confirms the identity of Align." It also says the strain is "clinically studied," but that is efficacy research, not independent contents testing.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:57:53
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
1 capsule
Servings/day
1
Pack size
63 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.95per day$59.99 per pack
#22

Florastor – 100 Capsules

Florastor

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
19/25
Value
10/20
Dose transparency
7/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
6/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Single strainYeastExact strainsCapsule1 live strain
Daily dose
Amount not stated
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
Florastor’s own product page says “Rigorous quality testing” and “Made in France, every Florastor Dual Action capsule meets the highest quality standards.” The Amazon listing also says “Scientifically-tested bio cultures complex with NCFM®,” but I did not find any independently verifiable third-party COA/certification for this specific product.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 14:03:15
Formulation & serving details
Format
Capsule
Serving
2 capsules
Servings/day
Not disclosed
Pack size
100 capsules

Full ingredients and formulation →

$1.36per day$67.99 per pack
#23

Thorne Complete Biotic – 30 Powders

Thorne

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
4/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
18/25
Value
9/20
Dose transparency
7/15
Manufacturer transparency
6/10
Label/ingredient transparency
7/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendPowderwith prebiotic
Daily dose
Amount not stated
Testing evidence
Evidence status
No public evidence located
Manufacturer statement
NSF Certified for Sport listing for Thorne® Complete Biotic on NSF's own registry shows the product name, brand, product form 'Stick', serving size '1 stick pack (1 g)', and the product is listed under Thorne in the certified products directory.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:39:55
Formulation & serving details
Format
Powder
Serving
1 powder
Servings/day
1
Pack size
30 powders

Full ingredients and formulation →

$1.53per day$46.00 per pack
#24

OLLY Probiotic + Prebiotic Gummy 0.5bn CFU – 30 Gummies

BetterYou Iron 10 mg Oral Spray

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
11/25
Value
9/20
Dose transparency
7/15
Manufacturer transparency
4/10
Label/ingredient transparency
8/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Not disclosedGummywith prebiotic
Daily dose
0.5 billion CFUBelow typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
OLLY product page states: "NSF Certified" and "NSF certification helps consumers identify products that have been independently tested and certified to meet rigorous standards for quality, safety, and label claims." NSF's own listing page for OLLY confirms the brand's certified products and includes "PROBIOTIC + PREBIOTIC" as a finished product under NSF/ANSI Standard 173.
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 14:03:40
Formulation & serving details
Format
Gummy
Serving
1 gummy
Servings/day
1
Pack size
30 gummies

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.43per day$12.87 per pack
#25

BioGaia Gastrus 0.2bn CFU – 30 Tablets

BioGaia

Why this score?
Testing & evidence
9/20
Ingredient/formulation quality
15/25
Value
6/20
Dose transparency
0/15
Manufacturer transparency
7/10
Label/ingredient transparency
7/10
Displayed points and weights are rounded; the total uses unrounded weights. Pending dimensions are excluded. Provisional scores may change after review.
Strains / formulation
Multi-strain blendExact strainsTablet2 live strains
Daily dose
0.2 billion CFUBelow typical rangeTypical: 2–50 billion CFU/day
Testing evidence
Evidence status
Testing claimed
Manufacturer statement
FODMAP Friendly product page for BioGaia product: “BioGaia® Gastrus™ PURE ACTION is an extra-strength probiotic... ✓ FODMAP Friendly ...” and “BioGaia® Gastrus® PURE is FODMAP Friendly® certified – it has been independently tested in NATA and ISO-accredited labs...”
Laboratory
Not recorded
Certification body
Not recorded
Batch
Not recorded
Batch-specific report
Not established in this record
Report date
Not recorded
Evidence checked
2026-09-27 13:37:31
Formulation & serving details
Format
Tablet
Serving
1 tablet
Servings/day
Not disclosed
Pack size
30 tablets

Full ingredients and formulation →

$0.58per day$17.50 per pack

One-time purchase prices; delivery and conditional discounts excluded. Daily cost uses the recorded label serving. Comparison amounts are not personal dose recommendations. Unknown Prime eligibility is not treated as confirmed.

Probiotic strains and labels explained

A high-quality probiotic comparison must separate microorganism identity, live count, shelf-life basis and formulation. The biggest CFU number or longest strain list is not a scientific efficacy ranking.

Exact strain disclosed

Best basis for evidence matching

Look for
Genus + species + strain ID
Example
L. rhamnosus GG

Species-only labels cannot be matched confidently to strain-specific trials.

Single strain

One defined live strain

Benefit
Clear evidence matching
Not a weakness
Fewer strains

A single well-researched strain can be more interpretable than a broad unstudied blend.

Multi strain blend

Several live strains

Compare
Exact blend + CFU
Do not assume
More strains = better

The finished combination needs evidence; individual-strain studies do not automatically add together.

Synbiotic formulation

Live microbes plus selectively used substrate

Scientific term
Evidence dependent
Not enough
Any added fibre

Use 'with prebiotic' unless the formulation genuinely meets synbiotic criteria.

Yeast probiotic

Live probiotic yeast

Example
S. boulardii
Do not convert
mg to CFU

Yeast probiotics may use different label units and antibiotic assumptions from bacterial strains.

Legacy taxonomy

Historical versus current names

Example
Lactobacillus → Lacticaseibacillus
Check
The exact strain ID

Names can change. Check the strain identifier before matching an older study to a current label.

Understanding probiotic strains and daily CFU

NIH uses colony-forming units (CFU) to describe viable probiotic organisms and states that there are no formal recommendations for or against probiotic use in healthy people. Optimal amounts depend on the strain and product, not a universal CFU target. [1]

For comparison, daily CFU is the verified CFU per labelled serving multiplied by labelled servings per day. Do not convert milligrams, AFU, total cells or postbiotic amounts into CFU.

Count timing is important because CFU can decline over shelf life. NIH distinguishes products that state CFU at manufacture from those that guarantee CFU through expiration/use-by. [1] [2]

What does the probiotic evidence say?

Probiotic efficacy is not a class effect. Trials and reviews repeatedly show that outcomes depend on the exact strain or blend and the condition being studied. [11]

For antibiotic-associated diarrhea, pooled outpatient evidence is positive for some products, but a large hospital trial of S. boulardii was null. [12] [14] For IBS, a dose-ranging 35624 trial found benefit at one tested dose but not at the lower or higher dose. [10]

That pattern is why this comparison does not award efficacy points for a large headline CFU number alone.

Probiotic evidence by research question

Evidence by goal
GoalEvidence strengthWhat was assessedTypical study contextMain limitation
IBS symptomsStrain-specific; mixed overallB. longum 35624 plus other exact probiotic strains/formulationsA 362-person trial found benefit at the 10^8 CFU 35624 dose over 4 weeks; systematic review results varied by strain/outcome.Clinical IBS populations; exact strain and final formulation are essential for applicability.
Antibiotic-associated diarrheaSupported for some products, not a class-wide effectSpecific bacterial mixtures, LGG/S. boulardii and other formulations17-RCT outpatient meta-analysis was positive overall; large null trials also exist.Different strains, doses, settings and antibiotic exposures.
Low bowel frequencyModest and strain-specificB. animalis subsp. lactis BB-121,248 adults received 1B or 10B CFU/day for 4 weeks with similar dose effects.Healthy low-frequency population; not a general constipation treatment conclusion.
Functional constipationRecent null evidence for one strainB. animalis subsp. lactis HN019229 adults; 8 weeks; 7.0B CFU/day at start and 4.69B by study end.One strain and population; does not determine effects of other products.
Read the full evidence-by-goal detail

IBS symptoms

Some exact strains have supportive human evidence, but a systematic review of 42 RCTs found effects varied by strain and outcome. [11] A different strain or blend should not inherit those results automatically.

Antibiotic-associated diarrhea

Some strain-specific formulations reduce risk in trials and meta-analyses, while other large trials are negative. [12] [13] [14]

Bowel frequency / constipation

BB-12 produced similar effects at 1 and 10 billion CFU/day in a large study, whereas a recent HN019 trial did not outperform placebo. [15] [16] More CFU is therefore not a universal efficacy rule.

Timing, storage and label directions

No universal morning/evening or empty-stomach rule applies to all probiotics. Follow the exact product directions and storage requirements. NIH notes that some probiotic products require refrigeration while others can be stored at room temperature. [1] [2]

Antibiotic-separation instructions should be treated as product-specific directions unless evidence for that exact probiotic/antibiotic context is verified.

Probiotic side effects and cautions

Who should be cautious?If any of the following apply to you, speak to a healthcare professional before taking Probiotics - see the full detail below for why.
  • People with compromised immune systems
  • People who are severely ill or medically fragile
  • People using probiotics to manage a diagnosed gastrointestinal condition
  • People receiving intensive medical treatment where probiotic organisms could pose a higher infection risk

NCCIH says probiotics have an extensive history of apparently safe use in healthy people, but safety has not been studied in detail across all products and long-term use. The risk of serious adverse effects is greater in people who are severely ill or have compromised immune systems. [3]

FDA regulates dietary supplements differently from drugs; sale of a probiotic supplement does not mean FDA has approved its clinical effectiveness. [4]

Combinations and interactions

Keep probiotics, prebiotics, synbiotics and postbiotics separate. A synbiotic is more than a capsule that happens to contain bacteria plus fibre; it has its own evidence-based definition. [6]

A postbiotic contains inanimate microorganisms/components and is not counted in live CFU. [7]

Who might consider probiotics?

For healthy adults, NIH does not make a blanket recommendation for or against probiotics. [1] The most defensible use of a comparison page is therefore to show whether a consumer product has the same strain/formulation and amount basis as research relevant to the shopper's question, without promising treatment.

People who are seriously ill, immunocompromised or using a probiotic for a diagnosed condition should involve a healthcare professional. [3]

Testing and quality: what to look for

For probiotics, identity, viability, stability and contaminant testing are separate. A DNA identity test can support strain identity but does not show how many viable organisms remain. A CFU result shows viable count at a timepoint but does not prove identity unless identity is also tested.

FDA cGMP requirements address manufacturing controls, identity, purity, strength and composition. [21] They are not independent evidence that the exact strain count survives to expiration or that the product produces a clinical benefit.

Testing evidence in this comparison

A testing claim is not the same as a verified report. No public evidence located does not mean a product has not been tested.

Testing review pending0
Recognised certification2
Verified independent evidence0
Manufacturer COA0
Testing claimed18
No public evidence located5

What does probiotics cost?

Current US comparison set, based on the daily serving shown on each label.

$0.07Lowest daily cost
$0.55Median daily cost
$1.53Highest daily cost

Your questions, answered

How many CFU should a probiotic have?

There is no universal best CFU count. NIH says optimal amounts depend on the strain and product. [1] A large BB-12 trial found similar effects at 1 and 10 billion CFU/day, which is one reason not to rank probiotics by the largest number alone. [15]

What is the difference between CFU at manufacture and at expiration?

Probiotic CFU can decline over time. NIH notes that some products list the count at manufacture while others state what remains through expiration/use-by. [2] The latter is more useful for knowing the live count when the product is actually used.

Is a multi-strain probiotic better than a single strain?

Not automatically. Probiotic efficacy is strain- and outcome-specific, and an unstudied blend does not inherit every benefit reported for its ingredients separately. [11]

Does FDA approve probiotic supplements before they are sold?

FDA regulates dietary supplements differently from drugs. Manufacturers are responsible for safety and labeling before marketing, and FDA can act against adulterated or misbranded products after they reach the market. [4]

Are probiotics, prebiotics and postbiotics the same?

No. Probiotics are live microorganisms, prebiotics are selectively used substrates, synbiotics combine live microorganisms with appropriate substrate(s), and postbiotics are inanimate microorganism preparations/components. [6] [7]

Sources & methodology

Read our methodology and how we verify testing.

Page updated26 Sep 2026
Editorial reviewSources checked 2026-09-26; editorial pilot
Product evidenceSee individual records